Combining Legal and Technical Expertise to Overcome Numerous Difficulties and Reverse an Unfavorable Judgment: An Engineering Quality Dispute

Keywords:

After obtaining an unfavorable first-instance judgment, the client entrusted our firm. In the second instance, the agent attorneys selected two institutions from the dual dimensions of industry professionalism and appraisal authority, coordinated the issuance of two expert opinions, and prepared a case search report. Through multiple measures, they creatively negated the first-instance appraisal method and overturned the first-instance appraisal report.
Using detailed legal and case search reports as well as thorough reasoning, the agent persuaded the judge that the case had not met the conditions for contract termination of “failure to achieve the contract purpose”. They also used visual charts to illustrate that the substantive reason for the opposing party’s claim for termination was its reluctance to continue investing.
In the end, the second instance directly reversed the judgment and fully supported all our claims, exceeding the client’s expectations. The victory was also maintained in the retrial.

Host Team

闵熹

闵熹

Partner

杨润来

杨润来

Partner

叶正伟

叶正伟

Partner

许明思

许明思

Lawyer